Friday, December 11, 2009

Edublogs Awards - Decline Nomination


Image Source: http://www.toothpastefordinner.com/060606/whats-better-than-a-cookie.gif

At the risk of being real "curmudgeony,"  I'm going to decline the 2009 Edublog Award nomination for Best Resource Sharing Blog. (and no one ever better suggest a lifetime award for me until I'm buried!).

Like a few others on the list--you know who you are--I find lists of exemplary blogs, voting for them, measuring their Technorati ranking a bit...well, counter-productive and repulsive. Those things are incidental to being a blogger, aren't they? But I've grown more mellow in my "old blogging age." People like to make lists, and do all that other stuff so...c'est la vie.

I appreciate those of you who sought to nominate Around the Corner-MGuhlin.org for the award (heck, any award) but I know the worth of my work and your daily comments and reading are affirmation enough. Since I've written why I blog many times before, I'm not going to go into detail again.

However, if the Edublog Award organizer persist in keeping a link to my blog, would you mind fixing my name? It's mis-spelled as "MGulin" when it needs to be "MGuhlin."

Thanks to all for your consideration!

That aside, here's a list of the nominees...please drop by and give them a visit, subscribe....


1. Best individual blog

  1. 2 Cents Worth
  2. Always Learning Blog
  3. Betchablog
  4. Blogush
  5. Blue Skunk Blog
  6. Dangerously Irrelevant
  7. dy/dan
  8. edte.ch
  9. Education Innovation
  10. elearnspace
  11. Free Technology for Teachers
  12. Ideas and Thoughts
  13. Informal Learning Blog
  14. Integrating ICT into the MFL classroom
  15. Jane’s eLearning Pick of the Day
  16. Joanne Jacobs
  17. Kalinago English
  18. Kathy Schrock’s Kaffeeklatsch
  19. Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites Of The Day For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL
  20. Learning Is Messy
  21. Learning Vision
  22. Learning with ‘e’s
  23. Making Change
  24. Moving At The Speed Of Creativity
  25. Open Thinking
  26. Pair-a-Dimes for Your Thoughts
  27. ProfBlog
  28. Scholastic Scribe
  29. Six Things
  30. Social Media in Learning
  31. Stephen Downes OLDaily
  32. Sue Waters Blog
  33. Teacher Reboot Camp
  34. The Ed Techie
  35. The Innovator Educator
  36. The Neverending Search Blog
  37. Weblogg-ed

2. Best individual tweeter

  1. AngelaMaiers
  2. BudTheTeacher
  3. butwait
  4. steve_collis
  5. courosa
  6. Darcy1968
  7. hjarche
  8. JaneBozarth
  9. jdeyenberg
  10. jenwagner
  11. joevans
  12. josiefraser
  13. KarenJan
  14. karynromeis
  15. Larryferlazzo
  16. Marisa_C
  17. msgregson
  18. msjweir
  19. moehlert
  20. mtechman
  21. olliebray
  22. psychemedia
  23. rliberni
  24. russeltarr
  25. shareski
  26. ShellTerrell
  27. sidneyeve
  28. thecleversheep
  29. tombarrett
  30. Tomwhitby
  31. web20classroom

3.  Best group blog

  1. 360
  2. Afgahn Women’s Writing Project
  3. A Year of Reading
  4. Blogging Pedagogy
  5. Committed Sardine
  6. Ed Tech RoundUp
  7. Ed Tech Talk
  8. I.N.K. Interesting Nonfiction for Kids
  9. Infinite Thinking Machine
  10. In Practice
  11. Jay P Greene’s Blog
  12. LeaderTalk
  13. Library Garden
  14. MacMillian Dictionary Blog
  15. Pontydysgu – Bridge to Learning
  16. ProfHacker.com
  17. Redbridge Games Network
  18. SCC English
  19. Sup Teach
  20. Teacher Voices
  21. Tech & Learning Advisor Blog
  22. The Adams 14 Global Learner Blog
  23. The Educators’ Royal Treatment
  24. Traditions Across Europe
  25. WorkPlace Learning Today
  26. Yalsa Blog

4. Best new blog

  1. Agnostic, Maybe
  2. Chris Leach
  3. Classroom Book of the Week
  4. David Cox’s Questions?
  5. Dr Brown’s Blog
  6. East Dragon Den
  7. Edgalaxy
  8. edVisioned.ca
  9. EFT Musings and other Tidbits
  10. I’m A Dreamer
  11. In the pICTure
  12. JonBischke.com
  13. Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice
  14. Ken Wilson’s Blog
  15. Kristen Winkler
  16. Learning to Speak ‘Merican
  17. Look At My Happy Rainbow
  18. Marisa Constantinides – TEFL Matters
  19. Mr. Wiemers’ Shop
  20. Ozge Karaoglu’s blog
  21. performance.learning. productivity
  22. Read…Write…Talk
  23. Reality 101: CEC’s Blog for New Teachers
  24. School Food Matters
  25. Sweeney Math
  26. TAGMirror
  27. The Educators’ Royal Treatment
  28. Teaching Village
  29. Teach Paperless
  30. Teacher Reboot Camp
  31. Technology Tidbits
  32. Thinking in Mind
  33. This Week’s Education Humor
  34. The Web 2.0 Optimist
  35. Trails Optional
  36. Webmaths
  37. West Coast Left
  38. Why Did the Chickenman Cross the Road?
  39. Zarcoenglish – Tools of the Day

5. Best class blog

  1. Alice Project
  2. All Saints Languages Blog
  3. Billings Middle School Tech Class Blog
  4. Borman Blogging
  5. Class 4OQ’s Blog
  6. Creative Voice
  7. East Dragon Den
  8. English With Rosa
  9. Extreme Biology
  10. Fab4@Work
  11. Forrester High School Int 2 Info Systems
  12. Gelincik Grubu
  13. Griffin Science – 8th Grade
  14. Huzzah!
  15. Intermediate English class blog
  16. Luce Semester 2009
  17. Ka Tangi Hoki Ko Au Room 15 Blog
  18. Law Primary School East Lothian Primary 6 Blog
  19. MrCs Class Blog
  20. Mr McClung’s World
  21. Mrs. Yollis’ Classroom Blog
  22. Ms Mourad’s Absolutely Sensational Learners
  23. Mrs Goerend’s Blog
  24. Planet Infinity
  25. Room 10 Grey Lynn School
  26. Room 18’s Learning Journey blog
  27. Room 231
  28. Rumford Writers
  29. Saint Exupery 6
  30. South Paris Collaborative Chat
  31. Tamaki Tales
  32. Tamaki Primary Blockbusters
  33. Technology in the Classroom
  34. The Greatest Middle School Blog in the World
  35. The Overlakes 6th Grade Blog
  36. The Skinny
  37. Think in English
  38. Watch Out!

6. Best student blog

  1. Adora’s Blog
  2. Allison’s blog
  3. Civil War Sallie
  4. Eric’s Blog
  5. Gamer’s Spot
  6. Jess
  7. Josh Halliday.com
  8. Moo
  9. Nicola’s ePortfolio
  10. Rachel e-learning
  11. Suzanne Yada
  12. TanNuj’s Weblog
  13. Tiffany
  14. Toreka Pt England School
  15. Universo

7. Best resource sharing blog

  1. Around the Corner – MGulin.org
  2. Aula de Física
  3. Don’t Waste Your Time
  4. Doug Off The Record
  5. edGalaxy
  6. Edte.ch
  7. Educational Origami
  8. Elearning Technologies
  9. Emerging Internet Technologies for Education
  10. Free English Lessons Online
  11. Free Resources for education
  12. Free Technology for Teachers
  13. Free Resources from the Net for EVERY Learner
  14. f(t)
  15. Jane’s E-Learning Pick of the Day
  16. Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day
  17. My English printable worksheets
  18. Nik’s Learning Technology Blog
  19. Open Culture
  20. Ozge Karaoglu’s Blog
  21. Sharing the Addiction
  22. Stephen Downes’s OLDaily
  23. Steve Spangler Blog
  24. Teaching the Civil War with Technology
  25. TeachPaperless
  26. Technology Tidbits:  Thoughts of a Cyber Hero
  27. The Exponential Curve
  28. Tim Rylands’ Web Log
  29. TipLine
  30. Welcome to NCS-Tech

8.  Most influential blog post

  1. Ann Marie Cunningham’s Tech addiction ‘harms learning’ …..really??? $24.99 and I am no wiser
  2. Anseo.net’s Head in the Clouds
  3. Danah Boyd’s Spectacle at Web2.0 Expo… from my perspective
  4. Dan Maas’s Writing with Laptops
  5. Burcu Akyol’s Spread Your Knowledge series
  6. Bud Hunt’s Would You Please Block?
  7. Dan Myer’s A Fifth Year Teacher’s Creed
  8. Dan Meyer’s What I Would Do With This: Groceries
  9. David Wiley’s A few notes about openness (and a request)
  10. Dean Shareski’s Student and Teacher blogging that succeeds
  11. Doug Johnson’s Where are the others?
  12. Intrepid Flame’s This, This, That
  13. James Clay’s The VLE is Dead – The Movie
  14. Jon’s A Manifesto for EduChange in the Eve of Hacking Education
  15. Joyce Valenca’s My 2.0 day and the response/rant about our cover argument
  16. Joyce Valenza & Doug Johnson Things That Keep Us Up at Night
  17. Liz B. Davis’s 10 Tips for Teaching Technology to Teachers
  18. Marisa Constantinides on  How to become an ELT Teacher Educator
  19. Martin Weller’s Using learning environments as a metaphor for educational change
  20. Michael Fienen’s The Great Keynote Meltdown of 2009
  21. Michael Smith’s Germ X Generation
  22. Scott McCleod’s Calling all bloggers! – Leadership Day 2009
  23. Sean Nash’s The Four Pillars of Technology Integration
  24. Shelly Terrell’s EdChat’s “Join the Conversation”
  25. Stephen Downes’s An Operating System for the Mind
  26. Steve Wheeler’s Another nail in the coffin?
  27. TeachPaperless’s Top Eleven Things All Teachers Must Know About Technology (or I promised Dean Groom I wouldn’t write a top ten list; so this one goes up to eleven.)
  28. Wes Fryer’s Debating the propriety of blanket censorship by school IT departments
  29. Will Richardson’s The Obama Speech
  30. Will Richardson’s Don’t, Don’t, Don’t vs. Do, Do, Do

9.  Most influential tweet / series of tweets / tweet based discussion

  1. Blogworthy Tweets
  2. #edchat
  3. #edayz09
  4. #geekpoll
  5. #lrnchat – #lrnchat blog
  6. #movemeon
  7. #ontarioplp
  8. #teachertuesday

10. Best teacher blog

  1. Always Learning
  2. Andrew B. Watt’s Blog
  3. Blogging About the Web 2.0 Connected Classroom
  4. Blogger in Middle-earth
  5. Blogush
  6. Box Of Tricks
  7. Cool Cat Teacher
  8. Continuous Everywhere but Differentiable Nowhere
  9. Darcy Moore’s Blog
  10. David Truss: Pair-a-dimes for your thoughts
  11. Division By Zero
  12. dy/dan
  13. edTe.ch
  14. f(t)
  15. iTeach
  16. Langwitches Blog
  17. Learn Me Good
  18. Life Feast
  19. Kelli’s Blog
  20. Mr Robbo – The P.E Geek
  21. Music is Not For Insects
  22. Musings from a Not-So-Master Teacher
  23. Nashworld
  24. Philly Teacher
  25. Pissed Off Teacher
  26. Practical Theory
  27. Science Teacher
  28. The Scholastic Scribe
  29. Tip of The Iceberg
  30. Tween Teacher
  31. Two Writing Teachers
  32. Welcome to NCS Tech

11. Best librarian / library blog

  1. A Fuse #8 Productions
  2. Bloggit
  3. Bright Ideas
  4. Blue Skunk
  5. Cathy Nelson’s Professional Thoughts
  6. Hey Jude
  7. LCS ES Media Blog
  8. Librarian by Day Blog
  9. Library Tech Musings
  10. Lucacept
  11. My Mind Gap
  12. Never Ending Search
  13. Not So Distant Future
  14. The Unquiet Librarian
  15. The Unquiet Library
  16. The Waki Librarian
  17. The Web Footed Book Lady
  18. Wired Librarian
  19. World’s Strongest Librarian

12.  Best educational tech support blog

  1. Assorted Stuff
  2. Blogging About the Web 2.0 Connected Classroom
  3. Box of Tricks
  4. Creating Lifelong Learners
  5. e4Africa
  6. Edte.ch
  7. Human
  8. iLearn Technology
  9. Langwitches
  10. Life Feast
  11. Nik’s Learning Technology Blog
  12. Open Thinking
  13. Ozge Karaoglu’s Blog
  14. Pipweks
  15. Rapid Elearning Blog
  16. Simulações e Animações Conceptuais no Ensino da Física e da Química
  17. Sue Waters Blog
  18. Teach 42
  19. Teachers Love Smartboards
  20. The Power Of Educational Technology
  21. Thumann Resources
  22. TechTicker
  23. The Edublogger
  24. The Innovator Educator
  25. The Whiteboard Blog
  26. Using ICT in Further Education

13. Best elearning / corporate education blog

  1. Adventures in Corporate Education
  2. Angela Maiers
  3. Assistive Technology
  4. El Camarote
  5. e-learning, conocimiento en red y web colectiva
  6. eLearning Technology
  7. elearnspace
  8. Janet Clarey
  9. Learning with ‘e’s
  10. Life Feast
  11. MPB Reflections — 21st Century Teaching and Learning
  12. Rapid Elearning blog
  13. Teaching Ideas and Resources
  14. Workplace Learning Today

14.  Best educational use of audio

  1. Aussiekids
  2. Bit by Bit
  3. Breaking News English
  4. Diane’s ESL Podcast
  5. EdTechTalk
  6. Gator Radio Experience
  7. Get Smart podcasts
  8. Kerry J’s Conference Coverage
  9. Kidcast
  10. Latin Poetry Podcast
  11. LearnTrends
  12. MediaSnackers
  13. MP Radio
  14. Musical Blogies
  15. My Audio School
  16. Podkids
  17. Seedlings
  18. SLF Talk
  19. Teacher 2.0 podcasts
  20. Teachers Teaching Teachers
  21. The A.T.Tipscast
  22. The Virtual Staffroom
  23. Tech Chicks Podcast
  24. Wesley Fryer
  25. Wicked Decent Learning
  26. Xyleme Voices features

15.  Best educational use of video / visual

  1. Angela Maiers
  2. Common Craft Plain English Series
  3. Bitacora de Ánibal de la Torre
  4. Brent Coley’s Study Cast & iPod Flash Cards
  5. Dan Meyer’s What Can You Do With This?
  6. Darren Elliot’s Lives of Teachers
  7. Dave Cormier’s “Presenting With Live Slides”
  8. Edit Foundry
  9. Hatak’s AP Chemistry Podcast
  10. Inanimate Alice
  11. ISTE Eduverse Talk
  12. Leon Cych’s conference recordings
  13. MediaSnackers
  14. Michael Wesch’s videos showcase
  15. Musical Blogies
  16. Rhett Allain’s Dot Physics
  17. Russell Stannard
  18. Saint Joseph Digital Express
  19. Smart History: The Blog
  20. Steve Spangler’s blog
  21. TEFLclips
  22. The Longfellow Ten
  23. Torley Linden
  24. Tom Barrett – interesting ways
  25. viz.: Visual Rhetoric — visual culture — pedagogy

16.  Best educational wiki

  1. Benson Bobcat Wiki
  2. Business English Online
  3. CDSPD
  4. Web 2.0 Cool tools for School
  5. Digitally Speaking
  6. East Dragon Den wiki
  7. EdOrigami
  8. Ed Tech Round Up
  9. Ed Tech Wiki
  10. EduWiki.us
  11. Greetings From The World
  12. Getting Tricky With Wikis
  13. HUMS3001: Censorship and Responsibility
  14. Indispensible Tools
  15. Introduction to Cultural Anthropology
  16. Joykaydia
  17. King/Chavez 3rd Grade
  18. Ktitraci
  19. Kohner wiki
  20. Learning For Content
  21. Learning Telecollaborative
  22. NDSL wiki
  23. Moving Forward
  24. One World Project Wiki!
  25. Open Education 09 wiki
  26. Open Thinking
  27. Ozge Karaoglu’s wiki
  28. PLN Yourself!
  29. Second Life Wiki
  30. Soar 2 New Heights
  31. Springfield Township Virtual Library
  32. Teaching with Thinking and Technology
  33. Teachmeet Wiki
  34. The File Cabinet
  35. The UDLTechToolKit
  36. Web 2.0 Guru
  37. WebTools4U2Use
  38. Wikieducator
  39. WSD’s eToolbox

17.  Best educational use of a social networking service

  1. Beth Still ISTE/ NECC Newbie Project
  2. Classroom 2.0
  3. Country Day School Ning
  4. Digiteen Ning
  5. Educator PLN ning
  6. EFL Classroom 2.0
  7. eLearning Professionals on Facebook
  8. Elementary Tech Teachers ning
  9. English Companion Ning
  10. Fireside Learning: Conversations about Education
  11. Independent School Educators Network
  12. LearnTrends Online Conference
  13. Mathematics24×7
  14. MSP2 Maths & Science Pathways Online Social Network
  15. OnlineProjects4Teachers
  16. Principles of Biology
  17. RSC Access and Inclusion Ning
  18. Saltashrainbow
  19. Second Classroom
  20. talk.ed
  21. Technology Integration in Education
  22. The Assistive Technology Ning

18.  Best educational use of a virtual world

  1. CANVAS (Children’s Art in the Virtual Arena of Scotland)
  2. DEN SL Blog
  3. Edunation
  4. ISTE’s Second Life island
  5. Reaction Grid
  6. SecondLife Education New Zealand
  7. School of Nursing, University of Kansas
  8. SIGMS in Second Life
  9. Sloodle
  10. The International Schools Island (isi)
  11. The UC Davis Virtual Hallucination simulation
  12. Virtual Graduation at the University of Edinburgh
  13. Virtual Macbeth – Angela Thomas
  14. Virtual Round Table Conference

19.  Lifetime achievement

  1. David Warlick
  2. Doug Johnson
  3. Jane Hart
  4. Jay Cross
  5. John Davitt
  6. Jo Kay
  7. Josie Fraser
  8. Judy O’Connell
  9. Karl Fisch
  10. Kevin Jarrett
  11. Larry Ferlazzo
  12. Peggy Sheehy
  13. Richard Bryne
  14. Scott McLeod
  15. Stephen Downes
  16. Steve Hargadon
  17. Sue Waters
  18. Vicki Davis
  19. Wes Fryer
  20. Will Richardson




    Subscribe to Around the Corner-MGuhlin.org



    Everything posted on Miguel Guhlin's blogs/wikis are his personal opinion and do not necessarily represent the views of his employer(s) or its clients. Read Full Disclosure

    16 comments:

    Joel Adkins said...

    I declined my nomination as well and the one they sent to add me to the list of nominated "best-of" anything. ;)

    Alfred Thompson said...

    I read those lists and I think of how few of them I read. And I read a lot of blogs! But in the best individual blog catagory I read perhaps 8-9 of the 37 nominated. I suspect that is more than many though fewer than some. What sense does it make for me to vote for one (any one) of those nominations? None really.
    So these voting things become mostly a popularity contest with people voting for their favorite blog. Do we know that the blog we like is better than one of the blogs we've never read? Of course not. It reduces the value of the effort in my opinion.
    To be nominated is nice but it means just as much to me if someone says "hey I like your blog and get a lot of value from it."
    Which reminds me, I really like your blog and get a lot of value from it.

    Tomaz Lasic said...

    I like it Miguel.

    The real honour is the nomination, competition (while understandable from promotional side of the Edublogs business) kinda misses the spirit of this whole thing we're in.

    Much like you, 1 write for pleasure & if someone else out there finds it useful - fantastic.

    Have a great Christmas break, may see you at/via the iMoot in January?

    Tomaz

    doug0077 said...

    Hi Miguel,

    You are an hombre after my own heart"

    http://doug-johnson.squarespace.com/blue-skunk-blog/2008/12/1/on-ranking-awards-and-other-nonsense.html

    Not only was I made to feel like I have one foot in the grave with this lifetime thing, but the nomination of "the most influential post" from the Blue Skunk was a guest post!

    I've decided some wrong this are just best ignored.

    All the best,

    Doug

    Barbara Treacy said...

    Hi Miguel -- just want to let you know how much I enjoyed meeting you/co-presenting with you at VSS and that I really appreciate your independent thinking and insights on this blog.

    ---Thanks! Barbara

    Miguel said...

    @Tomaz - iMoot? Yeah, right!! I wish I could attend but no disposable cash in my budget at the moment.

    Miguel said...

    @Doug - After your own heart? Well, that's HIGHER praise than anything I'd encounter. You forget, I've been reading your stuff since I was nigh high to a grasshopper.
    8->

    Miguel

    Moturoa said...

    A while back my class blog was nominated and in the final five for NZ blogging award. We didn't get anywhere and I was gutted.

    Would have been better never to have been nominated in the first place.

    Now feel like you- would rather not rank a blog by how many Twitter followers you might have or how big a school you work in.

    Have learnt my lesson- the hard way.

    Allanah K

    darcymoore said...

    It does seem a bit curmudgeonly ;O) but a point worth making. It is hardly surprising that this kind of thing would appeal to teachers, who spend a large percentage of their lives assessing the 'value' or 'worth' of others' work - and rewarding it!

    Basically, I agree with Tomaz and like the interaction the nominating process presents. It made feel good to nominate and be nominated!

    Probably the best thing about the Edublog Awards is that people can see a long list of blogs they may wish to subscribe and fnd some new folks to follow on twitter. This is pretty useful.

    BTW, ironically, or oddly enough, the Edublog Awards have led me too your blog again which I need to visit more often ;O)

    Have a great Silly Season, Miguel!

    TIm Holt said...

    Well, for the 4th year in a row, I was not nominated, so I couldnt decline. However, I did decline the "Sexiest Man Alive 2009" nomination from People Magazine.

    Actually, I applaud that stand.

    Gracias Miguel, well played.

    TBH

    Tim Holt said...

    Miguel,
    Here is my take on the Edublog Awards:

    http://snipurl.com/tnrad

    Tim Holt said...

    The conversation continues here:

    The first-ever UnEdublogger Awards for everyone that was not nominated for an Edublog Award.

    Post the link, then explain why it deserves everyone's attention.

    Everyone in the Unedublog Awards wins. You can nominate yourself as well.

    Here is the link:

    http://snipurl.com/tnz0r

    Daniel said...

    Hi Miguel,
    Thank you for nominating me for the best student blog category! Its such an honour to be nominated (my second nomination now though :D).

    Scott McLeod said...

    Don't be so cranky, Miguel. =)

    The Eddies have lots of holes. So what? It's all essentially harmless (unlike my blog rankings which are coming out soon!). Some good stuff gets recognized, some good stuff doesn't. Some stuff gets recognized that you don't like, other stuff gets ignored that's much better. I like seeing what others nominate 'cause I always find new blogs that I didn't know about.

    Hey, maybe we should have a blog playoff. Head-to-head voting competition. I can see it now. Will Richardson v. David Warlick in one semifinal, Vicki Davis v. Stephen Downes in the other. Winner-take-all blog death match!

    I'm going to nominate you for a Lifetime Achievement every year. Revenge for making me wear that sombrero when I came to San Antonio...

    C'est la vie exactly.

    Cathy Nelson said...

    LOL Scott! I've been campaigning for the Eddies to add an admin focused blog just for the likes of you, Doug, Miguel, others...

    And Miguel, I swear I had to read twice. I dd not pay attention to the heading and scrolled past it to begin reading. I thought after the first read it was a Blue Skunk writing!! LOL.

    Don't be so shy. I tell newbies all the time this is a good pace to "start" an rss reader, and then grow from there. Each year I put the ones Im not familiar with in an Eddies folder for consideration. As they pique my interest they get refiled in their right location in my reader. As I decide they dont appeal toe, I cut them away. It feels good to weed them out of my reader. Glad you have stayed and made the cut each year in my reader.

    Paul Bogush said...

    By the way, it must be easier to decline the nomination when your readership is in the triple digits eh? For those of us that are lucky to break ten hits on the day of a new post, a nomination just gives us a warm fuzzy feeling that someone went out of their way to say something nice about us.


    I would have left a comment but I ran out of time looking up the definition for curmudgeony ;)

    Subscribe via email

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Disclaimer

    Disclaimer

    Everything posted on Miguel Guhlin's blogs/wikis are his personal opinion and do not necessarily represent the views of his employer(s) or its clients. Read Full Disclosure